Auri vs. MUD\WTR
November 16, 2026 ยท 6 min read

Introduction
MUD\WTR built a loyal following as a coffee alternative: a cacao and masala chai powder with four functional mushrooms and a little caffeine from black tea and cacao.
It is a great ritual drink. But when you look at how the mushrooms themselves are made, the two products take very different paths.
This comparison lines up what each label says about the mushrooms, the caffeine, the testing and the price, so you can decide what matters most to you.
Quick orientation: main claims and who it's for
| MUD\WTRMUD\WTR Original | Super Mushroom Daily Gummies | |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | A cacao and masala chai drink mix with 4 mushrooms and about 35mg of caffeine | A caffeine-free gummy with 12 fruiting body mushrooms, studied in an 8-week open-label trial* |
| Best for | People replacing coffee who enjoy a warm, spiced morning drink | Anyone who wants a full daily mushroom dose with zero caffeine and nothing to prepare |
The MUD\WTR vs. Auri comparison chart
| Feature | MUD\WTR | Daily Gummies | Key difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| Format | Cacao and chai powder you whisk into hot water or milk | Two chewable wild raspberry gummies | No whisk, no frother, no mug. Two gummies and you're done. |
| Mushrooms | 4 (Chaga, Reishi, Lion's Mane, Cordyceps) | 12, including Lion's Mane, Reishi, Cordyceps, Turkey Tail, Chaga and Maitake | Three times the variety of mushrooms. |
| Mushroom amount | 2,240mg (560mg of each) | 300mg of 10:1 fruiting body extract per serving (made from about 3,000mg of whole mushroom) | Measured differently: MUD\WTR lists mushroom weight, Auri lists a concentrated extract. |
| Mushroom source | Label: "mushrooms and mycelium cultured on organic oats and/or organic sorghum." Brand says it uses both fruiting body and mycelium. | Fruiting body only, 10:1 low-temperature extract | Auri's label states fruiting body only. |
| Caffeine | About 35mg, from black tea and cacao | 0mg | Caffeine free. |
| Published human study on the finished product | None found in our research | 8-week open-label study on Daily Gummies (NCT07198399) | Studied on the exact product you buy. |
| Certifications and testing | USDA Organic. Brand says third-party tested. | Clean Label Project Purity Award, every batch tested by Eurofins | Certified for purity by an independent nonprofit. |
| Price per serving | About $1.67 one-time ($50 for 30 servings). About $1.33 on a regular subscription. | From $0.92 (3-bag subscription). $1.07 for 1 bag. | Three times the mushroom variety, with no caffeine. |
Fruiting body vs. fruiting body plus mycelium
MUD\WTR's label lists chaga, reishi, lion's mane and cordyceps "mushrooms and mycelium cultured on organic oats and/or organic sorghum," and the brand describes its blend as full-spectrum, using both the fruiting body and the mycelium. Mycelium is the root-like network a mushroom grows from.
Auri uses only the fruiting body, the mushroom itself, extracted at a 10:1 ratio with low heat. The best-known human trial on lion's mane (Mori et al., 2009) used fruiting body powder, which is one reason we made that choice. Both approaches have their supporters.
Four mushrooms vs. twelve
MUD\WTR gives you 560mg each of four mushrooms, 2,240mg in total. It is one of the more transparent labels in the category, which we respect.
Auri Daily Gummies include 12 mushrooms in 300mg of 10:1 extract per serving (made from about 3,000mg of whole mushroom), adding Turkey Tail for gut health and Maitake for heart health alongside the classics.
"Patients tell me they're exhausted, have brain fog, feel like they're getting old. I endorse Super Mushroom Daily Gummies and Focus Gummies. I take this product myself and I'm happy to share it with my patients."
Joel K. Kahn, MDCardiologist, Auri Medical Advisory BoardWhat our study found
We ran an 8-week clinical study on Super Mushroom Daily Gummies, registered on ClinicalTrials.gov (NCT07198399). 77.8% of participants reported sharper focus, 74.1% clearer thinking, 70.4% better memory and 62.9% felt more motivated. It was a single-arm, open-label study sponsored by Auri, with participant-reported results and no placebo group, so individual results vary.*
In our research, we did not find a published human study on MUD\WTR's finished product.
Price, taste and routine
At the time of writing, MUD\WTR Original is $50 for 30 servings one-time, or about $1.33 a cup on a regular subscription. It tastes like a spiced cacao chai and takes a few minutes to prepare.
Auri starts at $0.92 a serving and tastes like wild raspberry. If you love a warm morning ritual, MUD\WTR is a nice one. If you want your mushrooms to be effortless, Auri is built for that.
The final verdict
MUD\WTR is a well-loved coffee alternative with a clear label and a cozy ritual.
If the mushrooms are the reason you are buying, Auri gives you 12 fruiting body mushrooms, zero caffeine, a clinical study on the finished product and Clean Label Project certification, from $0.92 a day.
Try Auri risk-freeFrequently asked questions
Is mycelium bad?
No. Mycelium is a real part of the fungus, and some studies use it. Some brands, including MUD\WTR, use both fruiting body and mycelium. Auri chose fruiting body only.
Does Auri have caffeine?
No. Auri Daily Gummies are caffeine free.
Is Auri better than MUD\WTR?
They are different products. MUD\WTR is a coffee alternative drink. Auri is a daily mushroom supplement in a gummy, with 12 fruiting body mushrooms and no caffeine.

